My blog has moved!

You should be automatically redirected in 6 seconds. If not, visit
http://www.shockmd.com
and update your bookmarks.

Thursday, October 18, 2007

Internet based cognitive therapy for depression disappointing


Efficacy of Internet based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for depression and anxiety disappointing. In a recent meta-analysis CBT for depression and anxiety was modestly effective compared to placebo, care as usual, or waiting list conditions. There was also a significant heterogeneity between trials.

Heterogeneity:
Trials studying the same question are unlikely to have the same outcomes on the basis of sampling error. A difference between trials may be due to chance. It is important to know whether discrepancies between trials are greater than we would expect by chance. With heterogeneity the results of various trials are more different than one would expect by chance alone. In short the trials are different.

The authors next analyzed the trials with CBT for depression and anxiety separately (post hoc analysis). Again the effect size for depression treatment with CBT compared to the control conditions was small. CBT did not make the patients much better. Again there was significant heterogeneity. This heterogeneity could be accounted for by 1 single trial. This trial combined CBT with individual support. Maybe internet based CBT for depression with therapist support is efficacious. This lessens the advantages of Internet based CBT.

Advantages of Internet based CBT

1. anonymity
2. accessibility
3. avoiding the stigma of visiting a psychiatrist
4. treatment at any time and place
5. work at your own pace
6. review the material as often as as desired
7. reduction of therapist time
8. reach people through the Internet who might otherwise not receive treatment

Disadvantages of Internet based CBT:
1. No control on using the intervention
2. treatment sessions can be postponed infinitely
3. really on your own
4. can seem quite impersonal to participants

Levels of therapist involvement:

1. no assistance
2. contact by e-mail or telephone
3. face to face contact between sessions

Further research should focus on the efficacy of the amount of therapist involvement with the Internet based CBT for depression.

For anxiety the CBT had a large effect size and very low heterogeneity. It is hard to understand why Internet based CBT seems to work better for anxiety disorders compared to depression.

Limitations of this meta-analysis
1. small number of studies: 5 for depression, 7 for anxiety disorders
2. the post hoc analysis with subgroups such as depression and anxiety disorders resulted in in smaller groups and the power declined.
3. Uneven distribution of numbers of subjects across studies, the studies on depression all had large numbers of subjects, the studies on anxiety disorders all had small numbers of subjects
4. studies used different inclusion criteria for participants

Article discussed:
Internet-based cognitive behaviour therapy for symptoms of depression and anxiety: a meta-analysis.
PMID: 17112400
Authors: Spek V, Cuijpers P, Nyklícek I, Riper H, Keyzer J, Pop V
Journal: Psychol Med, 37 (3): 319-28, 2007



3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hi,
My name is Dan, I have run across your blog and I liked it a lot. I'm currently looking for partners for my new health blog http://health.infoniac.com. I would like to exchange links with you.

Look forward to hearing from you soon. You can email me at: health@infoniac.com

Best regards,
Dan.

James said...

A very interesting post. I've been reading up on online CBT lately, because the number of programs and planned programs are increasing very quickly.

The oldest one, MoodGym, has enjoyed all sorts of critical acclaim (to borrow a term).

I haven't heard much that isn't positive until now, but then your disadvantages are certainly valid and food for thought.

Dr. Shock said...

I was disappointed about the results of this meta-analysis. Keeping the limitations in mind the review was nicely done.
I think that CBT is one of the treatments that could be of benefit for a lot of depressed patients and can be easily implemented online. Probably some support is needed during online CBT. Maybe a forum or chat sessions are worth looking at when developing online CBT.